Index: /llms.txt # Montale Arabians Tonka Dupes 2026: 5 Clones vs the Original Five Arabians Tonka dupes, what named sources say about each, and how each differs from the Montale. 10ML sells the original Montale Arabians Tonka as a 3ml or 10ml decant to wear first. By [Antoine Mercier](https://10ml.com/authors/antoine-mercier) · Updated: 8 November 2026 · 9 min read **We sell only the originals.** Every perfume we sell is the authentic original, decanted from the perfume house’s own bottle. We buy our bottles from authorized EU distributors and directly from the brands, and 10ML decants every perfume itself. We never sell dupes, clones or inspired-by perfumes. This guide compares the dupes other houses make of Arabians Tonka, so you can choose, or wear the original first. [Or try the original from €8.10](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-arabians-tonka) ## Quick answer The best Montale Arabians Tonka dupe overall is Noir d'Arabie by Pendora Scents, which a Fragrantica member who owns the original and several alternatives names the closest. Timeless Tonka by House of Thêom has the lowest price, and Riiffs' Momento, which 10ML stocks, is a similar original. Want the real thing? Arabians Tonka is €25.11 for a 10ml decant at 10ML. You can try the original, [Arabians Tonka](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-arabians-tonka), at 10ML as a 10 ml decant, before you choose a dupe. ## Prefer the original? **Arabians Tonka** · Montale · Decanted from the original bottle - [3ml €8.10 · €2.70/ml](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-arabians-tonka?size=3ml) - [10ml €25.11 · €2.51/ml](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-arabians-tonka?size=10ml) The alternatives: €0.27–€0.60/ml in other shops, checked 28 September 2026 ## What does Arabians Tonka smell like? [Arabians Tonka](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-arabians-tonka) by Montale launched in 2019 as a unisex perfume. [Saffron](https://10ml.com/notes/saffron) and bergamot open it, a spiced and bright start. The heart sets [oud](https://10ml.com/notes/agarwood-oud) against Bulgarian [rose](https://10ml.com/notes/rose). The base is where the name earns its place: [tonka bean](https://10ml.com/notes/tonka-bean) and sugar cane over [amber](https://10ml.com/notes/amber), white musk and [oakmoss](https://10ml.com/notes/oakmoss). Its listed accords put sweet, vanilla and amber first, then warm spice, oud and rose, with a metallic, powdery edge running through. [Montale's own page for it](https://www.montaleparfums.com/en/oriental/282-arabians-tonka.html) gives the house's description. Sweet tonka is one way to wear amber; the [amber perfume guide](https://10ml.com/guides/amber-perfumes) also covers smoky incense ambers, powdery classics such as Shalimar and Dune, and fresh ambers built on bergamot and geranium. That is the puzzle every clone has to solve. The sugar and the tonka pull one way, the oud and the metallic saffron pull the other, and the rose sits between them. 10ML stocks one version of Arabians Tonka, so every clone below is measured against the same target. ## Arabians Tonka alternatives compared Bottle prices in other shops, as checked 28 September 2026 Perfumes made and sold by other houses. 10ML does not sell them. | # | Alternative | Role | Basis of comparison | Source | Bottle price | Per ml | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 1 | Noir d'Arabie (Pendora Scents) | Best overall | Named source | [Source](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Pendora-Scents/Noir-d-Arabie-104125.html) | €29.90 (100 ml) | €0.30/ml | | 2 | Cosmic Tonka (French Avenue) | Softer take | Named source | [Source](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/French-Avenue/Cosmic-Tonka-106866.html) | €36.99 (100 ml) | €0.37/ml | | 3 | Karus Secret Musk (Khadlaj) | Sweeter take | Named source | [Source](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/Khadlaj/karus-secret-musk/reviews/379759) | €39.90 (100 ml) | €0.40/ml | | 4 | Amber Oud Dubai Night (Al Haramain) | Fresher take | Named source | [Source](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Al-Haramain-Perfumes/Amber-Oud-Dubai-Night-96481.html) | €59.95 (100 ml) | €0.60/ml | | 5 | Timeless Tonka (House of Thêom) | Lowest price | Named source | [Source](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/house-of-theom/timeless-tonka/statements/2747505) | €19.95 (75 ml) | €0.27/ml | ## Best overall: Noir d'Arabie On paper, Noir d'Arabie by Pendora Scents follows the original closely. Its [published note list](https://www.pariscornerperfumes.com/products/noir-darabie) gives saffron and bergamot, then oud and Bulgarian rose, then [tonka bean](https://10ml.com/guides/tonka-bean-vs-vanilla), sugar cane, amber, white musk and oakmoss. Every note on Montale's published list appears there, and its base repeats all five of the original's base notes, the part you meet last. The main difference is strength rather than shape. A [Fragrantica member](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Pendora-Scents/Noir-d-Arabie-104125.html) who owns Arabians Tonka and several alternatives names this the closest of them, very strong and long lasting in their words, though below the original's power. Another member on the same page finds the rose lighter and the whole scent sweeter. It suits someone who wants the nearest match to the original's profile and can accept a little less power, or who finds the original's rose a touch heavy. Basis: named sources, the two Fragrantica members above and a [Parfumo member](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/pendora-scents/noir-d-arabie/statements/1990501) who calls it a great Arabians Tonka alternative. That member says it gets the scent very close, but does not perform quite like the original. ## Softer take: Cosmic Tonka Cosmic Tonka by French Avenue lists nearly the whole frame of the original. Its [Fragrantica page](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/French-Avenue/Cosmic-Tonka-106866.html) gives saffron and bergamot, agarwood and Bulgarian rose, then tonka bean, white musk, amber and oakmoss. Sugar cane is the one note from the original's list that it leaves off. The main difference is intensity. A Fragrantica member who knows the original well finds it very close, but a little smoother and more accessible. In that account the sweet oud hits less hard, and the scent performs slightly less. On [Parfumo](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/french-avenue/cosmic-tonka), members class it as similar and say they recognise the original straight away. One of them finds it better balanced, with the saffron less overpowering. It suits someone drawn to the original who finds its saffron or its sweet oud too insistent. Basis: named sources, the member write-ups on both databases. ## Sweeter take: Karus Secret Musk Karus Secret Musk by Khadlaj shares saffron, tonka bean, rose, amber, musk and oakmoss with the original, going by its [Fragrantica listing](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Khadlaj-Perfumes/Karus-Secret-Musk-102407.html). The same list adds red fruits on top, chocolate in the heart, and moss and ambergris in the base. No oud appears on it. If you want to meet that last note in other perfumes, our [ambergris perfume guide](https://10ml.com/guides/ambergris-perfumes) groups those that list it into fresh, soft, warm and sweet styles. The main difference is sweetness and texture. A [Parfumo member](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/Khadlaj/karus-secret-musk/reviews/379759) calls it an affordable Arabians Tonka alternative and the more similar of the two they tried, with the original's character clearly recognisable. They describe a very sweet opening with a lot of saffron, which then gives way to a dark, woody rose. A member on [Fragrantica's Arabians Tonka page](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Montale/Arabians-Tonka-57384.html), who owns Karus and tried the original, finds it less metallic, with a fuzzier tonka. It suits someone who finds the metallic edge of the original too sharp and wants the tonka rounder and sweeter. Basis: named sources, the two member accounts, with the notes from Fragrantica. ## Fresher take: Amber Oud Dubai Night Amber Oud Dubai Night by Al Haramain carries saffron, rose, oud, tonka bean and oakmoss on its [Fragrantica page](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Al-Haramain-Perfumes/Amber-Oud-Dubai-Night-96481.html), the core of the original's list. The main difference is brightness. The same listing adds elemi and lily of the valley. One member there finds it a little more sparkling and slightly fresher than Arabians Tonka, while still close in profile. Another member disagrees and finds little of Arabians Tonka in it. It suits someone who wants a brighter route to the saffron, oud and tonka idea, and who is happy to settle a split opinion on their own skin. Basis: a named source, the Fragrantica page, where members are divided. ## Lowest price: Timeless Tonka Timeless Tonka by House of Thêom undercuts every other priced pick in the table, both per bottle and per ml. [Parfumo's comparison page for the pair](https://www.parfumo.com/compare/house-of-theom/timeless-tonka/vs/Montale/arabians-tonka) lists saffron and bergamot, sugar and rose, then tonka bean and musk, all close to the original's list. It also lists cedarwood, geranium, amberwood and vanilla, and neither oud nor oakmoss. The main difference is the missing oud. [Fragrantica members](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/House-of-Theom/Timeless-Tonka-119276.html) find it similar to Arabians Tonka but without it. One finds the saffron harsh for the first half hour. Another says it does not smell like the original and suggests sampling it first. A [Parfumo member](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/house-of-theom/timeless-tonka/statements/2747505) calls it a softer alternative to the Montale, whose performance falls short and needs reapplying. It suits someone who wants the saffron and tonka side without the oud, for the smallest outlay, and who does not mind a second spray later. Before that second spray, it helps to follow the steps to [reapply perfume during the day](https://10ml.com/guides/how-to-reapply-perfume-during-the-day) in our guide: check for a real fade, then top up lightly on clean skin. Basis: named sources, with opinion split on how close it gets. ## Similar original perfumes we stock Original perfumes that share part of the saffron, rose and sweet amber character, each as a decant filled from the original bottle. | # | Perfume | Main notes | 3 ml | 10 ml | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 1 | [Montale Crazy In Love](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-crazy-in-love) | Wild rose and violet leaves, saffron and brown sugar over amber and vanilla bean: a rose-led, sugared take. | €7.83 (€2.61/ml) | €23.31 (€2.33/ml) | | 2 | [Mancera Instant Crush](https://10ml.com/perfumes/mancera-instant-crush) | Saffron, ginger and citrus over amberwood, rose and jasmine, with vanilla, sandalwood and oakmoss: woodier and brighter. | €7.56 (€2.52/ml) | €21.33 (€2.13/ml) | | 3 | [Montale Intense Cafe](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-intense-cafe) | Rose and coffee over vanilla, white musk and amber: a warm rose-and-coffee scent. | €7.02 (€2.34/ml) | €21.51 (€2.15/ml) | | 4 | [Montale Black Aoud](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-black-aoud) | Rose over oud and patchouli, with musk: the rose and oud pairing at its plainest. | €7.02 (€2.34/ml) | €21.51 (€2.15/ml) | ## What every clone gets wrong Two gaps come up in the member accounts above. The first is power. For Noir d'Arabie, Cosmic Tonka and Timeless Tonka, a member each describes a scent that performs below the original. The second is the rose. One member finds it lighter in Noir d'Arabie, and the whole scent sweeter. Once the rose steps back, the sugar has nothing to lean against. The note lists show a third gap. Among the lists quoted here, only Noir d'Arabie names sugar cane, and Karus Secret Musk and Timeless Tonka name no oud. The original works as a balance between sweetness on one side and oud with a metallic, powdery edge on the other. Take away one side and the whole scent tips. ## Full clone bottle or a small decant of Arabians Tonka? Counted per ml, all five clones in the table cost less than the original. A 10ml decant of Arabians Tonka is €25.11, or €2.51/ml. A 30ml is see the product page, or see the product page, the best value per ml we offer on it. If you are sure of the style and plan to use it generously every day, a large clone bottle holds more scent per euro. Per decision, the sums look different. A 3ml of the original, around 60 sprays, is €8.10. That is a small outlay next to a full clone bottle, and seven days of wearing it settles the question: the original, a clone, or nothing at all. For how Arabians Tonka compares per ml with the rest of the shelf, see the [price per ml index](https://10ml.com/guides/perfume-price-per-ml-index), and [what a perfume decant is](https://10ml.com/guides/what-is-a-perfume-decant) explains how the small bottles are filled. ## Authentic perfumes in the same family [Momento](https://10ml.com/perfumes/riiffs-momento) by Riiffs is a similar original that 10ML stocks. It sets sugar, saffron and mandarin over tonka bean, Damask rose and agarwood, then caramel, amberwood and cedar. Many members on its [Fragrantica page](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Riiffs-Perfumes/Momento-103346.html) find it close to Arabians Tonka, with the rose fading earlier and a sweeter, more caramel-like dry-down, and [Parfumo's comparison page for the pair](https://www.parfumo.com/compare/Montale/arabians-tonka/vs/riiffs/momento) classes the two as quite similar. Momento by Riiffs is one of four sweet and spiced picks in our guide to [Arabian perfume decants](https://10ml.com/guides/arabian-perfume-decants), together with Khamrah, Liquid Brun and 9pm. If you want part of this character from another original, four more perfumes we stock share some of it. [Crazy In Love](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-crazy-in-love) by Montale, from 2021, opens on wild rose and violet leaves, then saffron and brown sugar, and settles on amber and vanilla bean: a rose-led, sugared take. [Instant Crush](https://10ml.com/perfumes/mancera-instant-crush) by Mancera pairs saffron, ginger, mandarin and bergamot with amberwood, rose, jasmine and patchouli leaf, over vanilla, white musk, sandalwood and oakmoss. It is woodier, with more citrus at the start. [Intense Cafe](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-intense-cafe) by Montale sets rose and coffee over vanilla, white musk and amber, a rose-and-coffee route to warmth. [Black Aoud](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-black-aoud) by Montale is rose over oud and patchouli, with musk, the pairing at its plainest. All four come in 3ml, 10ml and 30ml sizes, so a few of them can share one week on your skin before you pick. Our house guide names [the Montale perfume to start with](https://10ml.com/guides/montale-perfumes), Black Aoud, and groups ten Montale perfumes into oud and wood, sweet coffee and vanilla, and spring and summer scents. ## How to test a dupe Judge a tonka-amber on your wrist, not a blotter, which shows you the opening and little else. Give the Montale a day to itself and the clone another day, so your memory of one does not tint the other. Note the first minutes and the heart of each. Leave the dry-down until later in the day before you judge it. The same logic applies at a perfume counter, where our tips to [test perfume in store](https://10ml.com/guides/how-to-test-perfume-in-store-without-pressure) suggest limiting skin tests to two or three perfumes, each on a separate clean patch. A 3ml of [Arabians Tonka](https://10ml.com/perfumes/montale-arabians-tonka) gives you a fair week of comparison. Should the Montale win, a 10ml decant (around 200 sprays) carries you through weeks of evenings, and the 30ml, around 600 sprays, is for keeps. For more on choosing before you commit, read [how to avoid a blind buy](https://10ml.com/guides/blind-buy-alternative). For the materials behind this scent, see our guides to [what tonka bean is](https://10ml.com/guides/what-is-tonka-bean), [what oud is](https://10ml.com/guides/what-is-oud) and [rose perfumes](https://10ml.com/guides/rose-perfumes). Before you settle on a full bottle, our guide to [safe blind-buy perfumes](https://10ml.com/guides/safe-blind-buy-perfumes) sorts twelve perfumes by how easy they are to wear, so you can choose what to try first in a small size. ## Clone or original? What to know first ### Can I try Arabians Tonka in a small decant first? 10ML sells Arabians Tonka as a 3ml, 10ml or 30ml decant filled from the original bottle and ships across the EU. A 3ml is around 60 sprays, enough to wear it for a week next to any clone. ### Do Arabians Tonka dupes cost less per ml than the original? Every clone in the comparison table costs less per ml than the original. A 10ml decant of Arabians Tonka is €25.11, and a 3ml is €8.10, a small outlay next to a full clone bottle. ### Which clone leads this Arabians Tonka ranking? Noir d'Arabie by Pendora Scents is the best overall pick in this guide: a Fragrantica member who owns Arabians Tonka and several alternatives names it the closest, and its published note list includes every note on the original's list. Members also say it sits below the original's power. ### How close is Noir d'Arabie to Arabians Tonka? Its published note list includes every note on the original's list, and a Fragrantica member who owns several alternatives names it the closest. Members also say it sits below the original's power, and one finds the rose lighter and the scent sweeter. ### Which Arabians Tonka dupe has no oud? Timeless Tonka and Karus Secret Musk list no oud. Fragrantica members find Timeless Tonka similar to the original but without the oud, and Karus Secret Musk adds red fruits and chocolate instead. ### Which version of Arabians Tonka are the clones compared with? 10ML stocks one version of Arabians Tonka, and every clone in this guide is compared with that one, using the note list Montale publishes. ### Which clones do sources tie most closely to Arabians Tonka? Among clones, Noir d'Arabie, Cosmic Tonka and Karus Secret Musk are the ones sources link most directly to it. Among the originals 10ML stocks, Parfumo's comparison classes Momento by Riiffs as quite similar, Crazy In Love shares saffron, sugar and amber, and Black Aoud shares the rose and oud. ### Will a 3ml show how long Arabians Tonka lasts on me? How long it lasts depends on your skin and the weather, so the fair way to find out is to wear a 3ml for a few days. For several clones in this guide, a member says the clone performs below the original. ### Does 10ML sell dupes? No. 10ML sells only original perfumes. We buy our bottles from authorized EU distributors and directly from the brands, and 10ML decants every perfume itself. The dupes in this guide are other houses’ perfumes, and we don’t sell them. You can wear the original first from €8.10. ## Sources - [Arabians Tonka, Montale](https://www.montaleparfums.com/en/oriental/282-arabians-tonka.html) - [Arabians Tonka by Montale, Fragrantica](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Montale/Arabians-Tonka-57384.html) - [Momento by Riiffs, Fragrantica](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Riiffs-Perfumes/Momento-103346.html) - [Member write-up on Arabians Tonka, Parfumo](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/Montale/arabians-tonka/reviews/703423) - [Arabians Tonka and Momento compared, Parfumo](https://www.parfumo.com/compare/Montale/arabians-tonka/vs/riiffs/momento) - [Noir d'Arabie by Pendora Scents, Fragrantica](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Pendora-Scents/Noir-d-Arabie-104125.html) - [Member statement on Noir d'Arabie, Parfumo](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/pendora-scents/noir-d-arabie/statements/1990501) - [Cosmic Tonka by French Avenue, Fragrantica](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/French-Avenue/Cosmic-Tonka-106866.html) - [Member write-up on Karus Secret Musk, Parfumo](https://www.parfumo.com/Perfumes/Khadlaj/karus-secret-musk/reviews/379759) - [Amber Oud Dubai Night by Al Haramain, Fragrantica](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Al-Haramain-Perfumes/Amber-Oud-Dubai-Night-96481.html) - [Timeless Tonka by House of Thêom, Fragrantica](https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/House-of-Theom/Timeless-Tonka-119276.html) - [Timeless Tonka and Arabians Tonka compared, Parfumo](https://www.parfumo.com/compare/house-of-theom/timeless-tonka/vs/Montale/arabians-tonka) ## How we compared Each alternative is ranked by how closely it follows the notes and dry-down of Arabians Tonka, on the basis shown for it in the table. Prices in other shops are as checked on 28 September 2026 and change often; the 10ML prices on this page are live. 10ML is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Montale or by the houses of the alternatives named here. Their names are used only to identify the perfumes compared.